Even the staunchest skeptics — if they get past the headline and see the way it’s designed can hardly complain about it.
Nobody is being put at risk. No standard medical treatment is being withheld. Nobody’s health is in the slightest jeopardy. In fact, those being studied don’t even know it’s happening.
The Kansas City Heart Rhythm Institute is testing 1,000 patients in intensive care with the contagion — with half getting a “universal” prayer offered in five denominational forms.
The four-month study will then compare death rates as well as time in ICU and on ventilators.
“We all believe in science, and we also believe in faith,” the study’s lead investigator, cardiologist Dr. Dhanunjaya Lakkireddy, told NPR.
“If there is a supernatural power, which a lot of us believe, would that power of prayer and divine intervention change the outcomes in a concerted fashion? That was our question.”
He stressed, “It has to be a true supernatural intervention.” —NYPost
It’s an intensive care version of Paschal’s wager. If there is nothing to prayer, then no harm done, but if there IS something to it, that’s good news for the guy getting prayed for.
Our main objection is the qualifier they’re putting out there. ‘True supernatural intervention’ sounds an awful lot like the ‘no true Scotsman’ fallacy. Worse, it’s an entirely subjective measurement.
A more neutral method would simply be to compare the health outcomes of the prayed-for group against the control group. If the difference is statistically significant, you have the basis for further investigation of the topic.
Get Doug Giles’ new book:
Rules For Radical Christians is not a survival devotional designed to help the young Christian adult limp through life. Rather, it is a road-tested, dominion blueprint that will equip the young adult with leadership skills and sufficient motivation to rise to a place of influence in an overtly non-Christian culture. Rules For Radical Christians gives the reader the keys to become strategically equipped to move into an anti-theistic environment and effectively influence it for the glory of God.