New Vatican Pronouncement On Mary Narrows The Gap Between Protestant And Catholics

The quickest way to start an online argument is to mention a topic where the stakes are highest and/or the diagreement is the most passionate. The proper Christian perspective on Mary, mother of Jesus is just such a topic.

For Roman Catholics, she is beloved, adored, even revered. It shows up in the way they pray, in the traditions they celebrate, and the stories about her that they share with one another. It stems, in part from the greek phrase Theatokos, which was formally adopted in the Council of Ephesus (431 AD) to affirm the Deity of Christ in opposition to sects that denied his deity. If Mary is known as the ‘Mother of God’, there can no longer be any doubt of who we mean when we speak of her son Jesus.

For Protestants, she is one of the great biblical examples of faithful women of God, who had the unique experience of being used of God in a way unlike any other human. She was a big part of helping Jesus grow to manhood, and even made appearances in his early ministry (Wedding of Cana). But for most Protestants, she plays no more role in actual acts of prayer or worship than, say, Jeremiah or Abraham might.

For many Protestants, who jealously guard the work of Christ on the Cross to redeem mankind as the unique role that none but the Son of God himself could take up is to profane the work of redemption itself.

And that brings us to the Vatican’s latest statement about which titles can be used to describe Mary, which should not, and which can be used only very carefully in specifically defined contexts.

As with any time someone moves the goal posts on a tradition, however important or mundane that tradition might be, some will criticize the change for being too modest, others will rage that it happened at all.

Catholics traditionalists with strong opinions about Mary will have something to say about this, and your typical Baptist or Presbyterian would point out all the other changes that should have been made, but this announcement makes one important pronouncement that narrows the gulf of division between the two groups.

First, a little about what is going on in this pronouncement:

The Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith on Tuesday, 4 November 2025, published Mater populi fidelis (“The Mother of the Faithful People”), a Doctrinal Note “On Some Marian Titles Regarding Mary’s Cooperation in the Work of Salvation.” Signed by the Prefect, Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, and the Secretary for the Dicastery’s Doctrinal Section, Monsignor Armando Matteo, the Note was approved by the Pope on 7 October.

Mater populi fidelis (MPF) is the fruit of a long and complex collegial effort. It is a doctrinal document on Marian devotion, centred on the figure of Mary, who is associated with the work of Christ as Mother of believers. The Note provides a significant biblical foundation for devotion to Mary, as well as marshalling various contributions from the Fathers, the Doctors of the Church, elements of Eastern tradition, and the thought of recent Popes. —Vatican News

The note breaks down the three categories.

• Titles that are still deemed ok (‘Mother of Believers’; ‘Spiritual Mother’; ‘Mother of the Faithful’)
• Titles that can be misunderstood from the accepted Roman Catholic use of the terms and should be used sparingly and carefully (Mediatrix of All Graces, for example) and could obscure the unique role of Christ’s redemptive work on the cross as the ONLY MEDIATOR, and cannot be used in any sense that doesn’t, itself, point to that work
• Titles that are inappropriate and problematic — like the title of Co-Redemptrix

Tuesday’s Doctrinal Note concludes: “It would not be appropriate to use the title ‘Co-redemptrix’ to define Mary’s cooperation. This title risks obscuring Christ’s unique salvific mediation and can therefore create confusion and an imbalance in the harmony of the truths of the Christian faith. […] When an expression requires many, repeated explanations to prevent it from straying from a correct meaning, it does not serve the faith of the People of God and becomes unhelpful”

If social media isn’t already lighting itself on fire over this news, it won’t be long.

Traditionalists will assuredly rally around well-worn terms for their beloved Mary that they’ve used for a little more than 100 years and rage against anyone who lifted a finger against them.

Pretty much every stripe of Protestant, (except the apostate/Liberal/Progressive camp, who are busying themselves with various political squabbles) will look at this announcement the way we might look at someone standing ankle-deep in water, when there’s a whole ocean waiting for you to come swim in it.

But it’s nice to say that whichever side we fall on, one thing is being held up as the central truth of Christianity.

Jesus, and Jesus ONLY, is the one who reconciles fallen man to a holy God, through his suffering, death, and resurrection, and our faith in his work on the cross.

And for that, despite all our other differences, believing Christians from both camps can rejoice together, both here, and into eternity.

The PERFECT Gift For The Art Loving Warrior

Dear Fellow Warriors: My new book just dropped, GILES VOL. I: The Biblical Warrior Collection. It’s a full color coffee table compilation of my biblical paintings over the last 20yrs. As you know, I don’t depict the biblical men in this book as sweet bearded women but rough troublemakers who shook all of hell’s habitations. It’s a great gift for the male and female scrappy warriors on your Christmas list. Young kids will love it too. 70+ original paintings. 234 pages with the scriptural inspiration behind each painting. It’s a beautiful book.

RECOMMENDATIONS. “One reason I buy Doug’s priceless art is to make bold statements on the walls of my home. Lively discussions come alive to bring home the Gospel messages behind the brushstrokes gifted to Mr. Giles. Pastor Doug’s creativity in canvassing the Biblical perspective is daring and courageous.”
– Captain Robert Reinecker

For bulk purchases (More than 5 copies) we’re offering 50% off list price of $69.95 if you purchase directly from the publisher. Email Skip Coryell at skipcoryell@hotmail.com for this offer.